Nick Davis
Check in #2
TO: Mikayla Beaudrie, Instructor of ENC 1101
FROM: Nick Davis, student in ENC 1101
DATE: July 25, 2014
SUBJECT: Progress of
Challenge, Gothic on the Tube
The film I chose for this challenge is the 1991 thriller, The Silence of the Lambs. One of the
main characters is a psychopathic prisoner named Dr. Hannibal Lector. His role
in this movie was to conference with a FBI agent who was trying to catch a
serial killer by gaining insight into the mind of a criminal. The reason the
agent is interviewing Dr. Lector is because he is in prison for not only
killing but also eating his victims. This criminal profile matches the
cannibalistic suspect that the FBI is after.
Cultural views of Cannibalism
The Gothic Hannibal
Lector is considered to be horrific simply because our society today sees
cannibalism as morally wrong and very gruesome. Although our culture sees this
act as evil, there are many primitive cultures who have been practicing certain
rituals for thousands of years that involve cannibalistic activities. The Amazonian
tribes deep in the rainforests of South America, for example, have had little
to no contact with more advanced civilizations and still continue to use
cannibalism as a religious and spiritual experience, Many cultures believe that
consuming the flesh or organs of a fallen enemy can give one the deceased’s
strength or contain some healing powers. To these cultures, Cannibalism is a
part of their way of life and do not see it as an evil act.
The Crime of Cannibalism
We can recollect some
instances of cannibalism in which the people were forced to indulge in this
brutal act for survival. In the story of the Donner Party during the 19th
century, this was exactly the case. The Donner Party was a group of American
pioneers that became stranded in a blistering mountain snowstorm that forced
them to do the unthinkable to survive. In the case of survival many have argued
that cannibalism is not a crime. Although it is both a moral and legal issue,
if there was no other way of finding some sort of food, it is human instinct to
do what is necessary to ensure the continued existence of our species.
However, Dr. Lector isn’t in a life or death situation
whenever he feels the impulse to indulge in his deadly habit. Furthermore, Lector
was not raised in a culture where cannibalism is considered a natural habit. His
dark curse was more than likely brought onto him at an early age after he
witnessed something very traumatic and emotionally scarring. This character
alone contains enough Gothic traits to be labeled as horrific or evil by a
standard society.